EditorsAbout the SiteComes vs. MicrosoftUsing This Web SiteSite ArchivesCredibility IndexOOXMLOpenDocumentPatentsNovellNews DigestSite NewsRSS
Boycott Novell

11.24.06

Microsoft Files Revised Documents with EC

Posted in Formats, Microsoft, Deals, Europe, Antitrust, Interoperability, RAND at 3:32 pm by Shane Coyle

CNNMoney reports that Microsoft has met the EC deadline, and has submitted revised documentation including the technical information required to interoperate with Windows. It will take months for the committee to review the documents to determine if Microsoft is now in compliance:

At the same time, a Monitoring Trustee appointed by the Commission will test the documentation.

If the Commission decides that the documentation is acceptable, it will face the question of whether the price Microsoft plans to charge for the protocols is justified.

Microsoft could face further fines if the Commission finds that the price was based on Microsoft’s exercise of monopoly power rather than on the originality of its product.

The price for the protocols? Wanna bet that price is in line with what Novell just agreed to pay, with similar restrictive license terms?* By agreeing to this deal, Novell is now saying that the Interoperability Protocols are indeed original, and deserving of licensing and paying royalties.

Novell is helping Microsoft exclude Free Software projects from interoperating with Windows without paying royalties, and then you won’t be able to redistribute the code - so I guess no GPL if you want to talk to Windows, or I suppose you could use Novell’s distro - it has patent indemnification straight from Microsoft.

* UPDATE:

I was digging some more, reviewing some old Groklaw articles from around the time of the Antitrust ruling, and stumbled upon an article from January 2005 that linked to Microsoft’s proposed terms for complying with the ruling. Read through the terms of the various license flavors (pdf links), and also review the program entry requirements including:

SECTION C: REQUIRED PAYMENTS

For each separate Work Group Server Protocol Program License Agreement for Development and Product Distribution identified in the table above as requiring a payment, a prepaid royalty payment of €50,000 is required. These prepaid royalties are nonrefundable unless your participation in the Work Group Server Protocol Program is terminated because you do not complete other Program Entry Requirements.

If you liked this post, consider subscribing to the RSS feed or join us now at the IRC channel.

Pages that cross-reference this one

Listed from October 23rd 2007 onwards, pingbacks and trackbacks (external) are omitted

Leave a Comment

What Else is New


  1. Marcel Gagné on Microsoft/Novell (Video)

    New episode that mentions our Web site



  2. Links 20/11/2008: IBM to Buy Transitive, China Helps GNU/Linux Development

    Links for the day



  3. IRC: #boycottnovell @ FreeNode: November 19th, 2008 - Part 2

    IRC Log for November 19th, 2008- Part 2



  4. IRC: #boycottnovell @ FreeNode: November 19th, 2008 - Part 1

    IRC Log for November 19th, 2008- Part 1



  5. How Bill Gates Sabotaged PCs to Make Business

    The story about OneCare being lumped in (to Windows) brings past memories of Gates' sabotage



  6. Sys-Con is Copyrighting Slightly Modified Press Releases

    Sys-Con turns press releases (about Novell staff in this case) into tweaked press releases with Sys-Con copyrights



  7. Novell's Moonlight Finds Fans: Microsoft Bloggers

    One of Moonlight's (and Mono's) biggest fan base is Microsoft



  8. The Analysts Know Everything

    Here is undeniable proof that analysts should not be listened to



  9. Patents Roundup: Microsoft Sues, Patents Critic Become Nobel Laureate, and More

    An extensive summary of news about software patents



  10. Waggener-Edstrom Behind the 2008 Laptop Bribes, Edelman Behind 2006's

    Waggener-Edstrom was this year's Microsoft 'proxy' for handling the Vista 7 [sic] laptops giveaway



  11. AstroTurfers Pretend to be GNU/Linux Users?

    Site trolls who pretend to be GNU/Linux users but actually use Windows



  12. Analyst Lies and Novell Business Growth

    Analysts refuted for bogus studies that align with their funders' desires



  13. Liability for Software When Life is at Stake

    Hospitals in the UK get shut down for choosing Windows and ceding control to crackers



  14. More Information About Microsoft's and Intel's Crimes Against Customers

    Microsoft helped Intel make $billions at customers' expense (more evidence appears)



  15. An Ode (Eulogy) to ISO

    ISO releases Microsoft's OOXML, so we have a quick stab at it



  16. Links 19/11/2008: Many New GNU/Linux-based Products, Linux Gets OpenGL 3.0

    Links for the day



  17. IRC: #boycottnovell @ FreeNode: November 18th, 2008

    IRC Log for November 18th, 2008



  18. Novell Information, in the Words of Anivar Aravind

    A lead protester tells the story about the recent incident in India



  19. We Can't Say “Microvell” Anymore

    An actual company “Microvell” is caught in the crossfire of bad publicity



  20. Calling Ubuntu, Fedora and OpenMoko to Resolve Mono Problem, Not Ignore It

    Sightings of Mono where it seem unnecessary; opposition to it suppressed



  21. Alex Brown Denies Manipulation, Insults Critics of Corruption

    Convenor the OOXML BRM is shamelessly insulting those who criticise the OOXML fiasco



  22. Microsoft Insults the People of China, Oman, the Newly-elected President

    Microsoft's arrogance is spinning out of control as it insults its own customers



  23. Quick Mention: Good Explanation of the Mono Problem

    A concise explanation of what makes Mono dangerous



  24. The Partner Group Smears Free Software Under Complimentary Disguise

    Gartner is spreading substanceless Free/open source software FUD (once again)



  25. Microsoft is “Crashing Parties” Again

    Adobe's product launch cannot go on without Microsoft interference



  26. Novell Removed from List of National Free Software Conference Sponsors?

    Aftermath of impacts of the action against Novell in India



  27. Links 18/11/2008: Flash for GNU/Linux Finally Embraces 64-bit

    Links for the day



  28. IRC: #boycottnovell @ FreeNode: November 17th, 2008 - Part 2

    IRC Log for November 17th, 2008 - Part 2



  29. IRC: #boycottnovell @ FreeNode: November 17th, 2008 - Part 1

    IRC Log for November 17th, 2008 - Part 1



  30. Eye on Microsoft: Feeling the Pinch Again

    A variety of news to show just how miserable things have become for Microsoft


An invade, divide, and conquer Grand Plan

Novell CEO Ron HovsepianHighlight: Novell was the first to acknowledge that Microsoft FUD tactics had substance. Novell then used anti-Linux FUD to market itself. Learn more

Xandros founderHighlight: Xandros let Microsoft make patent claims and brag about (paid-for) OOXML support. Learn more

Linspire CEO Kevin CarmonyHighlight: Linspire's CEO not only fell into Microsoft arms, but he also assisted the company's attack on GNU/Linux. Learn more

Hand with moneyHighlight: Microsoft craves pseudo (proprietary) standards and gets its way using proxies and influence which it buys. Learn more

Eric RaymondHighlight: The invasion into the open source world is intended to leave Linux companies neglected, due to financial incentives from Microsoft. Learn more

XenSource CEOAnalysis: Xen, an open source hypervisor, possibly fell victim to Microsoft's aggressive (and stealthy) acquisition-by-proxy strategy. Learn more

More analysis >>

Recent Posts